The great thing about this time of year is that you can request endless favourite tunes from the DJ and order endless favourite cocktails up at the bar without feeling in the least bit guilty about not doing any work. Merry Christmas everyone! And thanks for the drinks…
See you in all in 2012! 🙂
Although I’m still many mountains away from the terrifying moment that must be the Viva Voce, it was really worthwhile going along to yesterday’s discussion about what exactly is involved on the day. Some of MMU’s InfoComms PhD candidates have Vivas a few weeks from now, with others having only just “defended” successfully – meaning there were plenty of questions and stories (some of the horror variety) to share. What do the examiners expect of you? How should you prepare? What are the negative and positive sides of presenting your thesis? As someone pointed out, the Viva is a chance to discuss your work with people who have actually read it – in detail. They have probably even made notes in the margins! So overall, as well as inevitable terror, you should be pleased that at least two senior academics can reference your paragraph numbers and summarise whole chapters. Still, it’s a bit of a shame that PhD candidates in Manchester don’t have to wear colour-coded carnations and a subfusc as they do in certain UK Universities.
I was fascinated to learn from Emma-Reeta, a recently successful Finnish InfoComms candidate, that in her country (as well as in Sweden and probably elsewhere), the Viva Voce is a very public event and actually, a celebration. You might even end up with the whole thing appearing on You Tube!
I can’t imagine that happening in the UK, can you? It got me thinking (well, okay, got me thinking after our trip to the pub) about a question very important to my own infant thesis – what do we now define as the “Public Sphere” and how does it relate to the world of the University? The concept of the Public Sphere is most closely associated with Jürgen Habermas (and was popularised after the English translation of his Strukturwandel der Öffentlichkeit in 1989). In it he critiques the notion of a public/private divide with a focus on the “bourgeois” coffee houses of the 18th century – though, as he makes extremely clear, its roots go back much further, to the Enlightenment in fact. Naturally back then it was structured very differently, reflecting a different set of influences and priorities: most probably more democratic ones, more concerned as political thinkers of the day were with reason rather than commerce. Still, in essence, whatever period we consider, Public and Private have always been abstract, flexible and porous.
Many questions are being asked right now about the future of the Public Sphere which bring these ideas back into focus – from its increasing commodificiation and role in entertaining rather than informing private citizens, to the possibility of different systems of socio-cultural and political participation. This is most obvious if we think about mass media (including social media) as the pre-dominant forum for public dialogue today. Zizi Papacharissi borrows from theories of architecture to write convincingly of “the spatial effects of convergent technology on place.” Importantly, she states that “unless these spaces bear distinct connections to the systemic core of democratic institutions, their ability to effect institutional change is compromised.” However, as well as looking at what these spaces mean for
- Overtly political groups such as environmental activists, party- affiliated or single-issue campaigners
- Minority or “disenfranchised” communities, and inevitably,
- Consumer demographics or “market segments”
I think it is very much worth addressing what the changes and tensions between and within the Public and Private Spheres mean for the Scholar, not least to avoid a kind of artificial divide whereby academics are only visible or valued in so far as they contribute to the generation of money for business, or are on-hand to offer “expert comment” to the press.
To me, the idea of having to defend my thesis in public would be pretty scary. But if I imagine presenting and discussing my work in front of friends, family, loved ones, and anyone else interested in the topic – as well as having a big party afterwards – it seems like a valuable and special way of being recognised and welcomed into the public realm of academia. Beyond personal concerns, it is surely a great chance for Universities to make “visible” the effort involved in getting a PhD to people who may not ever want to do one themselves, and (important right now) who maybe aren’t always sure if Higher Education is something worth funding.
Over the past few days I have really started to feel like a student again. My mind is clearing itself some long-awaited space and I’m brimming with new ideas and a renewed enthusiasm. Somehow I have the sense that even when I’m busy, everything is more relaxed. For now at least. It’s strange to feel myself adjusting to the rhythms of a Studentship: and it’s undeniably positive. Of course, I’m very much aware of the privilege it represents to be a funded student again at this particular moment in time. For me, there are indeed “sunny uplands” – regardless of what The Lib Dems might have to say about the state of the nation. Upcoming challenges should be adventures rather than cause for alarm.
On Wednesday, (after another productive meeting with Jill and Frances), I collected my new ID card and finally visited the All Saints Library. Various staff members were around in the lobby to hand us colour coded leaflets explaining their collections, the building’s layout, and the newly revamped OPAC. No problem there since I don’t remember the old OPAC – and I like to think I already know a thing or two about searching library catalogues. But it was nice to have it explained anyway! It felt great to be back in the “stacks” and predictably my bag was bulging with books by the time I left. To my Supervisors: I promise that they are all 100 per cent relevant to my PhD! Two that will be at the front of the queue:
- Knowledge in a Social World, by Alvin I. Goldman. OUP. 1999.
- Designing Usable Electronic Text, by Andrew Dillon. Taylor & Francis. 1994.
Walking from the Geoffrey Manton Building to the Library means cutting through All Saints Park: a lovely green spot popular for al fresco sandwiches – and with a fruit and veg stall (as well as a burger van) parked outside. In summer, it would be nice to unwind and read on one of the park’s large seat-like chunks of stone. The next few weeks will definitely see me enter Bookworm mode as I start to prepare a mini literature review: though most likely inside.
Last night was my first proper outing to the pub: and a chance to meet some new faces from the department. We went to a scruffy wee place where drinks were cheap and where I didn’t need to feel in the least bit unglamorous about being patriotic and drinking Talisker. With ice and no mixer, naturally. Deirdre Hynes arrived to remind us all that it was “Arthur’s Day” (as in: Guinness, Arthur Guinness) and so the whisky was supplanted by a few half-pints of the Black Stuff. Delicious. Apparently Deirdre is something of a Digital and New Media expert and enthusiast, so I will definitely have to pick her brains soon about that!
Tonight I have a visitor arriving down from Glasgow: my Mum. Aww. No, she’s not bringing food parcels, sadly. But I have already booked us a table for 7pm at the Yang Sing. Apparently it’s one of the best Cantonese restaurants in the UK. Can’t wait to look at the menu. Watch out for the review. In the meantime: I have included (see above) a picture of the gorgeous Manchester Chinatown Gate.
Who am I?
This blog is about my Social Informatics research as a PhD student in the Department of Information and Communications, HLSS Faculty, Manchester Metropolitan University. It's also a space for thoughts, ideas, and descriptions of (any interesting) recent experiences.
Monthly archive of posts
- August 2015 (1)
- March 2014 (1)
- February 2014 (1)
- November 2013 (2)
- October 2013 (1)
- August 2013 (1)
- July 2013 (2)
- June 2013 (3)
- May 2013 (1)
- April 2013 (2)
- March 2013 (2)
- February 2013 (3)
- January 2013 (2)
- December 2012 (1)
- November 2012 (3)
- October 2012 (3)
- September 2012 (2)
- August 2012 (3)
- July 2012 (3)
- June 2012 (4)
- May 2012 (6)
- April 2012 (4)
- March 2012 (5)
- February 2012 (6)
- January 2012 (6)
- December 2011 (6)
- November 2011 (5)
- October 2011 (7)
- September 2011 (9)